Friday 12 December 2014

Article - Day Trading vs Position Trading Mentality

It is human nature to be impulsive,

irrational and incoherent.


999 times a man would turn right and then all of a sudden turns left to debunk the theory that that all turns are right handed turns. Logic itself dictates that the mere semblance of human rationality is itself at best a fluke aggregation of repetitive human behaviour that forms the slightest of patterns within a swirl  of endless possibilities.


On a micros sense; the individual is largely way out of control; largely indefinable, in spite of a sum of behavioral characteristics that would define some sort of shape. However; the larger we extend the group of individuality, the more definable the aggregation of human behavior. At a micro level; the independent human being is unique and largely unpredictable.


However, we do not live alone in this world; we live in groups with our fellow creatures. Essentially, we are social creatures, we move in social masses, and more importantly we tend to follow each other. This, at a macro level , is a group of individuals that have greater mass and shape and direction of thought. It is this macro level, the aggregation of a group of people, with their own  collective thoughts, joys, fears, anticipation, greed, desires and hopes that becomes the market definition of price action; for all prices today are but a mere reflection of the collective sum of human thought at that moment in time.



The trader profile by nature is an individualistic person, very much alone, very much the master or demon of his own universe. "Amongst them but not of them, wrapped in a shroud of thoughts" as Byron would have put it; self-centered, and self-assertive; his directions reflect none other than the micro level of human unpredictability. When we are in a group, as a herd we flow against the danger of stalking prey, we move in numbers, our mass gives us a sense of safety, our bulk a meaning and a purpose, and out collectivity a strength to persist. But when we are alone, we are bombarded with danger, our fears run amok and even jump at our own shadows. It because the trader, is an individualist, more often than not, in the long run, he will succumb. It not through the lack of effort, or commitment and drive and passion to grasp and learn; it is because the markets in the long run play a numbers game, cold, unemotional, facts and figures, that move in shapes and patterns, and the individual at times can fail to recognise this numbers game; where many a time the best thing a trader can do, is step aside, rid himself of all fear and expectation, and simply observe how the numbers draw out, how the zigs and the zags fade into trends, and the human impulse to pull the trigger and get right in there into the thick of the market action, could be quietened and stilled, through passive observation of the appearance of key moments that define the trend winds that we can catch and take a position.


We suffer into truth; the pain of playing roulette, the abysmal neglect of observation, by throwing ourselves into the fray and being in there just because we feel that we need to make a trade. All traders go through these juvenile phases and most will die, never to resurrect and mentally scarred to learn from their mistakes to commit to a new trading plan and strategy for success. We all get burnt taking positions on market open and then going through the indignity of a whipsaw that drags our positive into negative, and then we compound the misery by doubling up and accelerating our own demise. We have all been there with our demons on the screen making the worst possible choices because we imposed our own thoughts into the numbers game that cares not for the demise of yet another trader.

Day trading does not work. Period. From the nascent days of the hi-tech bubble in 2000 with people drawing on their home equity and credit card to trade internet stocks on a wave of hysteria, to the recent advent of forex trading portals with massive 100-1 and 200-1 leverage. People have been swallowed alive like a mere blip in an ocean where a single tsunami of market opinion can suddenly turn and does not present a freak occurrence but rather the norm. Through the thick and the thin, the art of swing trading, taking entry positions through chart analysis of key component indicators, is also a very dangerous premise. Swing traders typically plan for a 2-3 day event horizon; but the market is notorious and pull backs again can wipe out the swing trader as well as the day trader in but a moment.


On the other hand, a well calculated position trade with a well defined strategy to reach a certain price mark, coupled with adequate option hedging, has a longer run sustainability in the markets which merely play the numbers game. For once we are rid of the compulsive urge to glare at our screens day to day, and once we can see how the market moves in rhythms to numerical patterns in the longer run, then the chances of success, the probability of correct underlying assumption of price movement, is increased because at once we learn to move with the crowd, and against the short term noise that can lead us to doom and self destruction.


If masses of large speculative traders and institutional houses move in a pack with the numbers, then the best thing the individual trader can do is learn to follow in the footprints of the giants and look closely ahead at the horizon at the target number, across the dangerous landscape of ravines and thorns and danger. 


The futures markets for currency is a marvelous reference point, in that the weekly commitment of traders report, tends to identify patterns of large commercial trading. Coupled with longer term chart analysis, like the weekly and monthly charts, with the correct use of several pronounced indicators like moving averages, relative strength and Bollinger bands for longer term analysis, the position trader is able to collect more information and reach a clearer perspective than the day trader


In conclusion, upon reflection, in my view, true success, comes from learning to understand that we are truly alone out there in the markets, and truly we are so insignificantly small. Yet, in understanding our weakness comes our own internal strength. In the face of adversity comes the true grit that defines our very humanity. Once we can grasp the very nature of our true selves in relation to the universe, then only can we make the necessary steps in order to survive, and ultimately thrive within this market chaos. if only we have the the recognition that a selection of medium and longer term objectives through the study of patterns, will lead us to understand how the numbers game can finally move in our favor;  then only we could find it in ourselves with patience to understand and fashion a financial order for ourselves from chaos.

Pieter Bergli - DeLoren Trust Holdings 

Free Forex education for the betterment of a trader's livelihood


Disclaimer - U.S. Government Required Disclaimer - Commodity Futures Trading Commission

Futures and Options trading involves risks of losses. No representation is being made that any reader and account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those that are being discussed on this blog http://forexeducationperspective.blogspot.com/. The past performance of any trading system or methodology discussed is not necessarily indicative of future results.

CFTC RULE 4.41 - HYPOTHETICAL OR SIMULATED PERFORMANCE RESULTS HAVE CERTAIN LIMITATIONS. UNLIKE AN ACTUAL PERFORMANCE RECORD, SIMULATED RESULTS DO NOT REPRESENT ACTUAL TRADING. ALSO, SINCE THE TRADES HAVE NOT BEEN EXECUTED, THE RESULTS MAY HAVE UNDER-OR-OVER COMPENSATED FOR THE IMPACT, IF ANY, OF CERTAIN MARKET FACTORS, SUCH AS LACK OF LIQUIDITY. SIMULATED TRADING PROGRAMS IN GENERAL ARE ALSO SUBJECT TO THE FACT THAT THEY ARE DESIGNED WITH THE BENEFIT OF HINDSIGHT. NO REPRESENTATION IS BEING MADE THAT ANY ACCOUNT WILL OR IS LIKELY TO ACHIEVE PROFIT OR LOSSES SIMILAR TO THOSE SHOWN.

All trades, patterns, charts, systems, etc., discussed in this blog http://forexeducationperspective.blogspot.com/ are for educative and illustrative purposes only and not to be construed as specific advisory recommendations for actual trades. Disclaimer -  http://forexeducationperspective.blogspot.com/ bears no responsibility for the trading actions of its readers.